Starfield: A galactic mix of reviews and expectations

Bethesda /

Bethesda’s ambitious space-faring RPG, Starfield, has finally touched down, bringing with it a wave of expectations and apprehensions from players and critics alike. As fans eagerly anticipate an experience akin to “Skyrim in space,” initial reviews are unveiling a range of opinions, painting a mixed picture of the game’s reception.

Check out App Trigger’s review here!

Starfield’s anticipation has been building since its teaser at E3 2018. As an Xbox Series X/S console exclusive, early access started on August 31, with the full release scheduled for September 6. The game promises a sprawling “NASA-punk” adventure, where players craft their own spaceships, explore countless planets, and navigate tensions between rival colonial factions.

However, the early reviews have brought a mosaic of perspectives. Some critics applaud the game’s fulfilling promise of a Skyrim-inspired cosmic escapade, while others find it falling short, labeling it as uninspiring and unexceptional. The game currently stands with an 86 on OpenCritic and an 89 on Metacritic, signaling a range of critical reception.

The Washington Post’s Gene Park lauds Starfield’s central storyline as the best among Bethesda’s quests, balancing an expansive scope. On the other hand, Paste Games’ Garrett Martin praises exploration but critiques the writing, citing a lack of compelling characters and mysteries. This divide seems to stem from the game’s vast possibilities—while it mostly avoids bugs, its ambition leads to some pacing issues and uneven execution.

Notably, Kotaku’s review will arrive later due to Bethesda’s decision to withhold review copies. This time, they’re not alone, as several high-profile sites, including Eurogamer and The Guardian, were also denied early access. This limited access strategy hints at Bethesda’s desire to control the narrative around Starfield’s launch.

In the end, the true verdict on Starfield’s impact on the gaming industry remains uncertain. Like any colossal open-world RPG, it will take time to explore the depths of its content and judge its legacy. As players continue their interstellar journey, it’s clear that Starfield is sparking discussions around the intersection of ambition, execution, and expectation in the modern gaming landscape.

Gamespot emphasizes Starfield’s moments of excitement within its complex gameplay mechanics. The integration of satisfying gunplay into captivating questlines provides engaging combat experiences, even though the game struggles to deliver a cohesive RPG experience. The title’s approach to space exploration is described as novel, yet its portrayal lacks the depth found in other aspects of the game.

Polygon delves into the vastness of Starfield’s universe, revealing the daunting challenge of exploring a multitude of planets. Despite its extensive gameplay hours, the game’s vastness sometimes leads to a feeling of sterility. However, Polygon appreciates the game’s potential for unique moments, even if they’re often buried beneath layers of tedium.

Digital Trends takes an unexpectedly positive stance, praising the game’s imperfections for reflecting the resilience of human spirit. The review lauds the imperfect aspects of Starfield as a testament to the pursuit of dreams and aspirations. Even with its flaws, the game manages to inspire awe and wonder, invoking a sense of determination to reach for the stars.

Paste Games, while recognizing the ambition behind Starfield, critiques its execution. The exploration of space is paralleled with other renowned titles, yet Starfield falls short in comparison. The absence of compelling characters and a lackluster narrative dampen the overall experience, leading the review to conclude that the game’s ambitions don’t translate into an engaging gameplay loop.

GamesRadar commends Starfield for its stability and visual appeal. Despite minor technical issues, the game’s environments are beautifully detailed, providing an immersive experience. Moments of awe and wonder, such as witnessing a lightning storm over the sea during an exploration mission, showcase the game’s potential for memorable experiences.

PC Gamer’s review takes a more reserved stance, expressing disappointment in Starfield’s comparison to previous Bethesda RPGs. While acknowledging its moments of promise, the review highlights a lack of engagement and depth in its writing, characters, and faction quests.

Destructoid praises Starfield’s expansive narrative possibilities, citing instances where seemingly small choices lead to significant plotlines. The review acknowledges the game’s ability to create intriguing narratives within its spacefaring world, even suggesting that some of these plotlines could stand alone as separate games.

Game Informer appreciates Starfield’s unique position in the gaming landscape, offering players an immense galaxy to explore. Despite potential issues with pacing and focus, the review acknowledges the game’s rich content, inviting players to uncover a wealth of experiences in its imaginative sci-fi playground.

The Verge finds Starfield living up to its potential, offering a grand adventure centered around space exploration. The game remains faithful to Bethesda’s RPG formula, albeit with a cosmic twist. While the game adheres to certain conventions, it manages to capture the spirit of adventure and discovery.

VGC captures the overwhelming sense of scale in Starfield, comparing it to the awe of stepping out of Vault 101 in Fallout 3. The review celebrates the game’s ability to convey wonder and adventure across its expansive universe.

As Starfield continues to captivate players and critics alike, it’s evident that the game’s reception reflects a blend of ambition, execution, and personal expectations. The diverse range of reviews highlights the complexities of delivering a title that aims to redefine space-faring RPGs while living up to the legacy of Bethesda’s past successes. As players delve deeper into the game’s vastness, its true impact on the gaming industry will continue to unfold.