Madden 23 running back ratings leak: Who’s the best RB?

CHARLOTTE, NORTH CAROLINA - NOVEMBER 21: Christian McCaffrey #22 of the Carolina Panthers runs against the Washington Football Team during their game at Bank of America Stadium on November 21, 2021 in Charlotte, North Carolina. (Photo by Grant Halverson/Getty Images)
CHARLOTTE, NORTH CAROLINA - NOVEMBER 21: Christian McCaffrey #22 of the Carolina Panthers runs against the Washington Football Team during their game at Bank of America Stadium on November 21, 2021 in Charlotte, North Carolina. (Photo by Grant Halverson/Getty Images) /
facebooktwitterreddit

Madden 23 ratings continue to unofficially roll in and today we’re taking a look at the top-rated running backs in this year’s game. Again, these supposedly came from a leaked document from EA, but haven’t been confirmed or verified. But I love the debate that always surrounds player ratings, so I figured I’d share them with you.

At the top of the ratings list is none other than Derrick Henry. The Titans’ workhorse checks in with an overall rating of 97, the highest in Madden 23. For years, Henry has been the most dominant ball carrier in the NFL, eclipsing the 2,000-yard mark in 2020. Injuries derailed his season last year, but he still managed to put up 937 yards and 10 touchdowns in eight games.

Last year, Henry began the season as the second-best running back in Madden 22 with a 96 overall (one point behind Carolina Panthers’ golden boy Christian McCaffrey). The knock on Henry has been he’s too one-dimension, although EA’s ratings adjustors blamed it on his Carrying and Trucking rating.

Henry flirted with the Madden 99 Club last season, but only reached as high as a 98 overall. He finished the season as the top-rated running back in Madden 23 with a 97 overall.

Perhaps the most surprising shake-up in the top Madden running backs is the leap of Jonathan Taylor. While many consider him to be the best half-back in all of the NFL right now, the 23-year-old checks into Madden 23 as the second-best running back with a 96 overall. However, I could easily see him leapfrogging Henry during the season if he plays like he did last year.

Rounding out the top five running backs in Madden 23 are Nick Chubb (96 OVR), Dalvin Cook (95 OVR) and Christian McCaffrey (95 OVR). EA maintains that injuries don’t impact a player’s rating and that does seem to be the case for McCaffrey who has struggled to stay on the field consistently the past two seasons. When healthy, McCaffrey is a game-changer. He can do it all which is why his 95 overall is warranted. The problem in real life is he can’t stay healthy. As long as he continues to produce while on the field, he’ll remain a top running back in Madden 23 despite his injuries.

Next. Madden 23 wide receiver ratings leak: Cooper Kupp, Davante Adams top the list. dark

Check out the top running back ratings in Madden 23, per the unconfirmed leak:

  1. Derrick Henry – 97 OVR
  2. Jonathan Taylor – 96 OVR
  3. Nick Chubb – 96 OVR
  4. Dalvin Cook – 95 OVR
  5. Christian McCaffrey – 95 OVR
  6. Joe Mixon – 94 OVR
  7. Alvin Kamara – 92 OVR
  8. Austin Ekeler – 92 OVR
  9. Aaron Jones – 90 OVR
  10. Saquon Barkley – 87 OVR
  11. Najee Harris – 87 OVR
  12. Kareem Hunt – 86 OVR
  13. Josh Jacobs – 85 OVR
  14. Melvin Gordon – 85 OVR
  15. Ezekiel Elliott – 85 OVR
  16. Cordarrelle Patterson – 85 OVR
  17. Leonard Fournette – 85 OVR
  18. Chris Carson – 84 OVR
  19. James Conner – 83 OVR
  20. James Robinson – 83 OVR
  21. David Mongomery – 83 OVR
  22. Javonte Williams – 83 OVR
  23. D’Andre Swift – 83 OVR
  24. Cam Akers – 82 OVR
  25. Antonio Gibson – 82 OVR
  26. Damien Harris – 81 OVR
  27. Miles Sanders – 81 OVR
  28. Devin Singletary – 80 OVR
  29. JK Dobbins – 80 OVR
  30. Elijah Mitchell – 80 OVR
  31. AJ Dillon – 79 OVR
  32. Clyde Edwards-Helaire – 79 OVR

Next. Madden 23 leak: Top rated quarterbacks draw debate. dark

I know I said I love the debate surrounding player ratings in Madden but if these are true, then I think EA nailed them. I think Henry deserves the honor of being the best-rated until proven otherwise. But Jonathan Taylor is an up-and-coming star and easily deserves second best. Again, with weekly updates, it’s quite possible either Henry or Taylor jumps into the 99 Club at some point next year.

What do you think of the Madden 23 running back ratings? Do you agree with them, if true?